Assessing Ethical and Social Challenges in Newborn Screening ResearchPublic Square #03Published November 21, 2016
This month’s public square focuses on the ethical and social consequences of adding a new condition to newborn screening panels.
It can be hard to know which medical conditions should be added to state newborn screening panels. Experts review pilot studies to weigh the benefits and harms of screening all babies for the new proposed condition. In the past, these pilot studies usually did not explore ethical and social issues. For example, should the state newborn screening program tell a family if their child is a carrier for a disease but does not actually have the disease?
A team of researchers and newborn screening officials wrote ethical and social questions for researchers to include in pilot studies. The table linked below puts these questions in boxes to help researchers think of all the questions that they may want to study. In this public square, we are seeking your input on this table.
1. Are there ethical or social issues we are missing in this table?
2. Are there stakeholders we are not including that should be added to the table?
3. Are there questions or sections in the table that are unclear?
4. Do you have any other general comments about the content or the layout of the table?
The moderator of this public square will inform participants at least 2 weeks in advance of the public square's last day for comments. Please add your comments and thoughts by then. Also, make sure to check back to see other responses and continue the discussion! We appreciated your input and feedback on this important document.